Forms of Disputes and Methods of Resolution in Vietnam

Forms of Disputes and Methods of Resolution in Vietnam

Dispute in Vietnam could arise between parties to a business transaction, such as the government of Vietnam and foreign investors, or between nations implementing international treaties.

Vietnam's market economy developed in tandem with a significant increase in the breadth and depth of its economic ties, which have made Vietnam an important component of the global supply chain. Vietnam providers could offer the labor and products to the world and the unfamiliar provider could likewise trade their labor and products to Vietnam market. Further, as the Vietnam market opens up, unfamiliar financial backers could put through different types of interests in Vietnam for example gain values in Vietnam organizations, lay out business inVietnam. Disputes that have grown in size and complexity during this process are an inevitable outcome.

The majority of people should agree that disagreements should be interpreted as disagreements, inconsistencies, or conflicts of interests, rights, and responsibilities between parties in economic relations at various levels. Accordingly, economic disputes can have the following basic forms:

-Disputes in business are between the participants in a business transaction including investments, production to consumption of products or performance of services on the market for profit purposes i.e. professional and product liability, debt disputes over a business transaction, franchise disputes, intellectual property disputes, and disputes over contract for supply of goods or services…

-Disputes between foreign investors with Vietnam government agencies, arising in the implementation of the BTO, BT, BOT, and the implementation of international agreements on promotion and protection bilateral and multilateral investment i.e. government policy and policy measures, concession to water and sewerage, power or energy supply, project or contract payment…

-Disputes between countries in the implementation of the international bilateral and multilateral agreements.

After taking into account a variety of factors, including cost, time, and the complexity of the disputes, the parties involved in disputes in Vietnam may consider resolving the issues through negotiation, mediation, arbitration, or litigation. In Vietnam, a litigation law firm with skilled dispute lawyers in Hanoi, Danang and Ho Chi Minh City should be consulted for appropriate dispute resolution advice.

Read More

When Labour Dispute over Bonus Issue Arise and How to Resolve?

When Labour Dispute over Bonus Issue Arise and How to Resolve?

According to the provisions the Labor Code, the bonus, also known as the “other supplement”, is one of the main contents of the Labor Contract. Specifically, bonus is understood as a sum of money paid by an employer to the employees on the basis of annual business results and the level of work performance of employees. When the dispute arises, the employer or the employee could consult with labour dispute lawyers in Vietnam to handle the matter effectively.

Related post: How to Resolve Disputes in Labour in Vietnam?

Bonus regulations of each company must be decided and publicly announced by the employer at the workplace after consultation with the representative organization of the grassroots-level employees’ collective. However, there are companies that do not specify bonus regulations or companies with unclear bonus regulations referring to such generally as “based on capability”, or “based on work results” without referring to specific key performance indicator (KPI). Such regulations will easily cause labor disputes. In most of the case, the employee would face disadvantage because the employer will be the one whom make the final decision on whether or not the capability or work results are satisfied.

A labor dispute means a dispute over rights, obligations and interests among the parties during the establishment, execution or termination of labor relation; a dispute between the representative organizations of employees; a dispute over a relationship that is directly relevant to the labor relation. Labor disputes over bonuses can be individual labor disputes or collective labor disputes. The competence authority to settle labor disputes belongs to the Labor Mediator, the Labor Arbitration Council, and the People’s Court. Normally, individual labor disputes or collective labor disputes must go through the mediation procedure of the labor mediator before referring to the court to settle, unless otherwise provided for by law.

For individual disputes, in case the conciliation is unsuccessful or either party fails to implement the agreements in the minutes of successful conciliation or the settlement time limit expires but if the labour conciliator fails to conduct conciliation, each disputing party has the right to request a court or arbitration council for settlement.

For collective disputes over bonuses, in case the conciliation is unsuccessful or one of the two parties fails to implement the agreements in the minutes of successful conciliation, the parties have the right to request the President of the district-level People’s Committee to resolve the dispute. If the parties disagree with the decision of the President of the People’s Committee of the district or beyond the time limit but the President of the People’s Committee of the district does not settle, the parties have the right to request the Court to settle. In such situation, a litigation lawyer would be engaged to assist for productive result. 

ANT Lawyers – A law firm in Vietnam, always follow up the labour matters to update clients on regular basis.

 Source ANT Lawyers : https://antlawyers.vn/library/when-labour-dispute-over-bonus-issue-arise-and-how-to-resolve.html

Read More

How Probation is Regulated in Vietnam Labor Code?

How Probation is Regulated in Vietnam Labor Code?

An agreement between an employee and employer for a probationary position for a predetermined amount of time in accordance with legal requirements is known as probation. Both the employer and the employee should go through a trial period before signing a labor contract to see if they can work together in the long run. The Labor Code and other relevant guidelines should be followed during the probation. The Labor Code 2019 comes into force as of January first, 2020, various new guidelines likewise are given in association with the probation, which each organization ought to audit the matter with labour dispute lawyers in Vietnam for compliance.

Concerning conditions which are allowed to go into a trial contract, this agreement isn't material to the work term which is under multi month. The Labor Code 2012 doesn't need that the trial arrangement should be specified in the work contract. As a result, an employer and employee may negotiate the probation, as well as their respective rights and responsibilities during the probation period. If the parties are in agreement about the probation, they can sign a probation contract. The employer is required to sign an employment contract with the employee if the probation work meets the requirements. It is clear from these provisions that a separate probationary contract between the employer and employee is required.

When the probation period is over and the employee satisfies the employer's recruitment requirements, the labor contract should be signed. Employer and employee may agree on a separate probationary contract or the probation that is outlined in the labor contract, as per the most recent provisions of the Labor Code for 2019. If the labor contract includes a probationary period, the employer is obligated to continue carrying out the current agreement once the employee has met all of the requirements. In that case, a new labor contract must be signed.

Based on the nature and complexity of the job, the Labor Code decided how long the probation period had to be. For positions requiring a college degree or higher, the probationary period was previously limited to no more than 60 days. Currently, executives can extend their probationary period by up to 180 days. The owner of a sole proprietorship, the partner of a partnership company, the chairperson or member of the Board of Members, the President of a company, the President or member of the Board of Directors, the Director/General Director, or the holder of another managerial position prescribed in the company's charter (applicable to the enterprise without state capital) are examples of executives who play a significant part in the business and operation of the businesses.

Another amendment to the cancellation of the probationary contract, the Labor Code 2019 removed the limitation of the right to cancel. Accordingly, during the probationary period, each party has the right to cancel the probationary contract or labor contract entered into without prior notice and compensation. On the contrary, the employee and the employer may cancel the probation if the probationary job does not meet the requirements that the parties have agreed upon under the Labor Code 2012.

The primary purpose of probationary periods is to determine whether an employee and employer are compatible at the outset of an employment relationship. To avoid a potential dispute in Vietnam, businesses as employers must have a clear understanding of the principles of entering into a labor contract and a probationary contract.

Read More

How does the Vietnam Labor Code regulate probation?

How does the Vietnam Labor Code regulate probation?

Probation is an understanding between a representative and a business on a trial work in a specific timeframe as per the arrangements of regulation. Both the employer and the employee should go through a trial period before signing a labor contract to see if they can work together in the long run. The Labor Code and other relevant guidelines should be followed during the probation. The Labor Code 2019 comes into force as of January first, 2020, various new guidelines as needs be are given in association with the probation, which each organization ought to  review the matter with its labour dispute lawyers in Vietnam for compliance.

This contract does not apply to employment for less than one month, regardless of the circumstances under which it may be entered into. The probationary clause is not required to be included in the labor contract by the 2012 Labor Code. As a result, an employer and employee may negotiate the probation, as well as their respective rights and responsibilities during the probation period. If the parties are in agreement about the probation, they can sign a probation contract. On the off chance that the probation work meets the necessities, the business will finish up a work contract with the representative. It is clear from these provisions that a separate probationary contract between the employer and employee is required.

When the probation period is over and the employee satisfies the employer's recruitment requirements, the labor contract should be signed. As per the most recent arrangements in the Labor Code 2019, the business and the representative might settle on the probation expressed in the work contract or a different trial contract. If the labor contract includes a probationary period, the employer is obligated to continue carrying out the current agreement once the employee has met all of the requirements. In that case, a new labor contract must be signed.

Based on the nature and complexity of the job, the Labor Code decided how long the probation period had to be. For positions requiring a college degree or higher, the probationary period was previously limited to no more than 60 days. Currently, executives can extend their probationary period by up to 180 days. The owner of a sole proprietorship, the partner of a partnership company, the chairperson or member of the Board of Members, the President of a company, the President or member of the Board of Directors, the Director/General Director, or the holder of another managerial position prescribed in the company's charter (applicable to the enterprise without state capital) are examples of executives who play a significant part in the business and operation of the businesses.

The Labor Code 2019 made another change to the cancellation of probationary contracts, removing the restriction on the right to cancel. Consequently, during the probationary period, either party may terminate the labor contract or probationary contract without penalty or prior notice. On the other hand, if the probationary job does not meet the requirements that the employer and employee have agreed upon under the Labor Code 2012, the probation may be terminated.

The primary purpose of probationary periods is to determine whether an employee and employer are compatible at the outset of an employment relationship. To avoid a potential dispute in Vietnam, businesses as employers must have a clear understanding of the principles of entering into a labor contract and a probationary contract.

ANT Lawyers is an international law firm in Vietnam with English speaking lawyers, located in the business centers of Hanoi, Danang and Ho Chi Minh City with international standards, recognized by IFLR1000. We are Vietnam exclusive member of Prae Legal, an international law firm network, providing full ranges of legal services.

Read More

How Really does Debate Settlement System of WTO Work

How Really does Debate Settlement System of WTO Work?

The dispute settlement procedures used by the World Trade Organization (WTO) are based on the GATT 1947 dispute settlement rules, which have been in place for nearly 50 years. Finding a positive solution to the dispute is the fundamental goal of this dispute resolution method. Because Vietnam is a member of the World Trade Organization, it may use the WTO's dispute settlement mechanism in disputes with other WTO members.

The parties to a dispute at the World Trade Organization (WTO) will first hold consultations to come up with a mutually agreed-upon solution to the dispute (Consultation – the stage of mediation). Third parties, who are members with a significant interest and desire to participate in the dispute resolution process, may participate in each case if they feel they have a significant interest in the case and should be considered by the panel. On account of a fruitless request, a board of 3 to 5 individuals will be laid out and entrusted with looking at a specific issue in debate based on WTO rules refered to by the petitioner's country.

According to Article 12.3 of the DSU, the first thing a panel to review the complaint must do is establish a timetable for its proceedings. The contents of Article 12 and Annex 3 of the DSU are typically covered by the panel procedure, which allows for some flexibility to guarantee the quality of the report without delaying the proceedings. The parties can be more proactive in presenting evidence, bases, and arguments in their submitted documents by understanding the contents and deadlines of a timetable.

The panel will enter the internal discussion phase (deliberation) following the hearings to evaluate the assessment of relevant legal and practical issues in accordance with WTO regulations. The deliberation must be kept secret. The parties to the dispute were not present when these reports were written; rather, they were written based solely on the information that was provided and the remarks that were made earlier. Individual assessments of hearers introduced in a board report will exclude the names of speakers of such sentiments.

Within two weeks of the panel's conclusion of the mid-term review, the final report will be sent to the dispute parties. Regularly, every report of the board has extremely huge substance, to work with the investigation of audit by the redrafting body and to cite case regulation, the report should show the chapter by chapter list and sections which are discrete numbered in the request for the report. After the DSB adopts a panel report, the dispute resolution process will immediately proceed to the implementation stage if there is no appeal. The case will be reviewed at the appellate level if there is an appeal.

As a member of the World Trade Organization, Vietnam must be well-versed in the dispute resolution process and fully prepared for disputes with other WTO members in international trade disputes.

ANT Lawyers have Litigation and Dispute lawyers in Hanoi, Da Nang and Ho Chi Minh City that help clients dealing with dispute resolution and alternative dispute resolution in Vietnam.

Read More

Languages in Arbitration Proceedings in Vietnam

What are Languages in Arbitration Proceedings in Vietnam?

Article 10 of the Vietnam Law on Commercial Arbitration says that if both parties are Vietnamese, the language used in arbitration proceedings to settle a dispute is Vietnamese, or a language agreed upon by both parties if one of them is a foreign-owned business. Specifically:

Except for disputes in which at least one party is a foreign-invested enterprise, the language of arbitration is Vietnamese for disputes with no foreign component. A dispute party may employ an interpreter if it is unable to speak Vietnamese.

For questions including unfamiliar components or debates to which no less than one party is an unfamiliar contributed undertaking, the gatherings will agree on the language to be utilized in arbitral procedures. The arbitration council will decide on the language to be used in arbitration proceedings if they do not have such an agreement.

Arbitration lawyers in Vietnam can also help clients with a variety of issues, such as choosing an arbitrator, choosing the rules for the arbitration, choosing an ad hoc or institutional arbitration, choosing a location for the arbitration, and getting an arbitral award enforced.

Read More

When Arbitration Lawyers in Vietnam Could Settle a Dispute?

When Arbitration Lawyers in Vietnam Could Settle a Dispute?

Under the Law on Business Mediation powerful Jan first, 2011, and other directions, on a basic level, discretion must be utilized in questions among parties that emerge from business exercises, debates among parties something like one of whom conducts business exercises, and different debates among parties which are specified by regulation to be settled by intervention in Vietnam. From drafting the arbitration agreement to resolving the arising dispute, an arbitration lawyers in Vietnam should be consulted.

Arbitral tribunals are entitled to resolve the disputes mentioned above if the concerned parties have a valid arbitration agreement agreed, before or after the dispute arises.

At the point when the court is mentioned to determine one of the debates of the above sorts which a legitimate discretion understanding exists, the court will look at records encased with the request to decide and in the event that the court observes that the question is under a mediation understanding and such assertion understanding is substantial the court will give a choice to end the settlement, return the request and reports.

The question will be dealt with by the court however it is under a discretion arrangement, except if generally concurred by the gatherings concerned or endorsed by regulation: the court gives a choice to dissolve the arbitral honor or the choice made by the arbitral council; or on the other hand there is a choice to suspend the arbitral council or mediation focus from settling questions; or on the other hand the mediation arrangement isn't suitable.

ANT Lawyers, a Vietnam-based law firm, will be available to help clients resolve disputes outside of court, in court, or through arbitration lawyers in Vietnam.

Read More

What are the Arbitration Principles of Dispute Resolution?

What are the Arbitration Principles of Dispute Resolution?

Arbitration, mediation, negotiation, and litigation are all methods of dispute resolution. For disputes to be resolved, a law firm in Vietnam needs dispute lawyers who have the expertise and experience necessary to resolve complex cross-border, commercial, and civil disputes.

The following principles must be followed when settling a dispute in arbitration, according to Article 4 of the Vietnam Law on Commercial Arbitration:

If the parties' agreement does not violate social ethics or prohibitions, arbitration lawyers must respect it.

Arbitrators must be independent, objective and impartial and shall observe law.

Parties in dispute have the same rights and responsibilities. The arbitration council is responsible for establishing the conditions necessary for disputing parties to exercise their rights and fulfill their responsibilities.

Dispute settlement by arbitration shall be conducted in private, unless otherwise agreed by the parties.

The arbitral awards are final.

Discretion has turned into a very famous technique for question goal, as numerous organizations lean toward it over the significant expenses of prosecution.

Arbitration lawyers in Vietnam may also be able to assist clients with a variety of issues, including choosing an arbitrator, choosing the rules for the arbitration, selecting an ad hoc or institutional arbitration, selecting a location for the arbitration, and obtaining the enforcement of the arbitral award.

Read More

8 Important Steps Guide to Establish Company in Vietnam

8 Important Steps Guide to Establish Company in Vietnam

It is possible for foreign investors to establish company in Vietnam. Foreign investors have the right to choose the appropriate forms of enterprise such as a limited liability company, joint stock company... with particular steps including:

Step 1: Register the investment project to establish company in Vietnam

Investors submit a registration file for an investment project to the business registration office of the province, city, or management board of an industrial, export processing, or high-tech zone for approval within 15 days (without additional time for clarification).

Step 2: Apply for Certificate of investment registration

Investors can apply for a business registration certificate in Vietnam by submitting a valid record to the Department of Planning and Investment within ten days of the investment project's approval.

Step 3: Apply for the certificate of business registration

After obtaining the business registration certificate, the investor shall submit the application for enterprise registration certificate to the enterprise registration office within 3 days.

Step 4: Publish the content of the business registration

Within 30 days of receiving the certificate of enterprise registration, the investor is required to disclose the following information about the company on the national enterprise registration portal:

i, Business lines;

ii, List of founding shareholders and shareholders being foreign investors for joint-stock companies.

Step 5: Registered business stamp

The form, quantity, and contents of the company's stamp are entirely up to the business. The following information must be displayed in the stamp's content:

-Company’s name;

-Business code.

After receiving the legal entity stamp and before using the business stamp, the enterprise must send a notice on the stamp of the enterprise to the business registration office for publication in the National Information Portal on the business registration.

Step 6: Notice of use of stamp

Investors send notices on use of stamp forms to the Investment registration agency after getting a stamp. The Investment registration agency stamps samples of businesses, branches, and representative offices for businesses, publishes the business's notice on the National Business Information Portal, and issues a receipt for the business following receipt of the record.

Step 7: Open bank account

Financial backers need to open two sorts of ledgers, to be specific the speculation capital record to get the venture sum and the exchange represent going through with everyday exchange in Vietnam.

Step 8: The post licensing procedures

For the conditional business lines:

Investors investing in conditional business lines as defined in Appendix 4 of the Investment Law 2014 are required to have professional liability insurance, a certificate of business qualification, practicing certificates, and other documentation… prior to directing business in Vietnam.

Read More

How Does the ASEAN Dispute Resolution Mechanism Work?

How Does the ASEAN Dispute Resolution Mechanism Work?

Having an efficient means of resolving disagreements that arise between member nations has become an essential requirement as economic cooperation has grown. As a result, ASEAN has been working on a Protocol on a Dispute Settlement Mechanism since 1996. On November 20, 1996, ASEAN Economic Ministers signed the Protocol in Manila (Philippines).

Dispute Settlement Mechanism of ASEAN

The spirit of negotiation and mediation is the foundation of ASEAN's dispute resolution system. Parties to the dispute in Member States have the option to select mediation methods at any time. These structures might start or end out of the blue. The complainant took the matter to the Senior Economic Officials Meeting of ASEAN (SEOM) only after the mediation process had ended. Mediation procedures will continue to apply while the dispute is ongoing if the parties to it agree.

The matter will be referred to SEOM if the consultation does not resolve the dispute within sixty (60) days of receipt. SEOM will either form a panel or, if that is not possible, send the matter to the special rules and procedures team or another group for evaluation. However, in some instances, SEOM may decide to settle the dispute without appointing a panel if deemed necessary.

Within thirty (30) days of the panel's submission of the report, SEOM will evaluate it during its discussion and make a decision regarding the dispute. SEOM may have an additional ten (10) days to resolve a dispute in exceptional circumstances. Parties to the dispute may be represented by SEOM representatives at the meeting, but they may not vote on SEOM decisions. SEOM will decide by majority vote.

Within thirty (30) days, parties to the dispute may appeal the SEOM's decisions to the ASEAN Economic Ministers (AEM). Within thirty (30) days of receiving the appeal, AEM must issue a decision. AEM may have an additional ten (10) days to resolve the dispute in exceptional circumstances.

ANT Lawyers have Litigation and Dispute lawyers in Hanoi, Da Nang and Ho Chi Minh City that help clients dealing with dispute resolution and alternative dispute resolution in Vietnam.

Read More

Methods of Dispute Settlement in International Trade

Methods of Dispute Settlement in International Trade

When drafting international contracts in international trade, the parties typically pay little attention to the terms of dispute resolution and instead focus more on payment and expense terms. As a result, both parties ought to be aware that disagreements and disagreements can occur at any time. As a result, the parties to an international economic agreement ought to pay attention to the provisions regarding the various options for resolving disagreements in the event of one. There are currently four methods of dispute settlement in international trade: negotiation, mediation commercial arbitration, and court.

Negotiation

In international dispute resolution, negotiation is typically used as a method of resolution. Particularly, the parties talk together, fight, come to an agreement, and settle the dispute. The dispute may or may not be resolved as a result of the negotiation. There are two methods used in negotiations: The two parties meet in person to discuss and negotiate, or one party submits a complaint to the other and the other responds.

Mediation

Mediation is a process in which a neutral third party helps the disputing parties reach an agreement. There are two methods for mediating: One is that the parties are in agreement regarding mediation, that the mediator will be chosen, and that the mediation will be conducted without following any mediation rules. The subsequent way is that the gatherings consent to direct the intervention under rules of an expert association or one explicit discretion establishment, for example, intercession rules of the Worldwide Office of Trade (ICC).

Commercial arbitration

Arbitration is a method for resolving disputes arising from trade activities that parties agree upon and are carried out in accordance with the order and procedures. Currently, there are several types of arbitration, including: permanent arbitration and ad hoc arbitration.

Court

The three above methods of dispute resolution are voluntary. They are distinct from dispute resolution in accordance with court procedures. Disputes should be resolved through the efforts of state tribunals, not by court settlement. As a result, litigants in the dispute are frequently viewed as the ultimate means of safeguarding their legitimate interests. In particular, parties will choose trade negotiation or mediation over commercial arbitration or court when there is a conflict.

ANT Lawyers, a Vietnam-based law firm, regularly informs clients about the status of dispute resolution in international trade cases. We have dispute lawyers in Hanoi, Da Nang and Ho Chi Minh City with qualification and experience to assist client to resolve dispute in Vietnam.

Read More